Is it better to do a thing badly or not at all?
To answer the question, Is it better to do a thing badly or not at all? I take refuge with something I say a lot these days.
It depends.
We need both motivation and caution, bravery and guile. A tag team of two players works well if one has the courage, another focuses on detail.
As I get older and bolder, personally I tend to the view that it is better to do a thing than sit and think about it, or wish I had done it. I hate regrets. I hate saying, ‘If only I’d had the courage to get on with that ….’ and knowing I could have done something to help life turn out differently.
I would rather have a go at something, perhaps starting small until I gain the confidence to attempt something bigger. There is only one way we learn, after all, and that is by making mistakes; by realising that mistakes are only stepping stones, questions to answers we haven’t found yet.
Who would object to us getting a thing wrong? Authors and writers are not in the habit of creative catastrophe, are we? We’re unlikely to burst the dam, to send someone to their death or to motivate someone to evil… That being so, we really have to decide to go ahead one day, to live without having all our ducks in a row, before we know the answers, before we can be sure.
Unlike in real time, where we build a path, then walk along it, in creative attempts, our path – our luck, our outcomes – are the result of a decision, a choice we make, to do something; at which point, the path comes to meet us as we walk along it. There are no guarantees with that process, except that there is a lot we can learn.
Please share:
Diane Dickson
September 20, 2017 @ 3:51 pm
I think that it all depends on what you mean by ‘badly’. If you mean in a slapdash, careless way that results in something that you are dissatisfied with, then maybe it is better to move along and shelve the idea because there will be no gratification. If on the other hand you mean do it to the best of your ability and the end result is something that is perhaps a little less than you were hoping for, but is all that you know you could achieve, then yes do it and i don’t think that is doing something badly, it’s doing your best and that’s a whole ‘nother thing. No?
Fran Macilvey
September 20, 2017 @ 5:24 pm
Dear Diane, thanks so much for your comment! 🙂
Yes, I agree. Language is very subjective, isn’t it? But I think, coming from perfectionist tendencies myself, I would still prefer to endorse the slap dash approach – which tends, anyway, to often be a matter of opinion, I suspect, having been a purist for too long. If we are slap dash, that is also useful, since we can then decide whether we wish to continue with it, brush it up, work on our attitude, or whatever. At least slap dash is active. Which I suspect, for me, is probably way better than wishing and dreaming and hesitating because one is fearful of not getting it perfect first time. (You can tell what my lessons have been, can’t you?!)
Elouise
September 25, 2017 @ 4:23 pm
Great topic, Fran. I’ve come to rely heavily on doing something rather than nothing. Just sitting there waiting for words to come can last a lifetime (zzzz). Sometimes words or images just pop out and I can’t get them down on paper/computer fast enough. But the other times–I just dump whatever it is into a file and look the next day. There’s almost always a thread of something I’d missed entirely….thankfully.
On the other hand, if we’re talking about a project, I endorse doing something as a beginning. Not so much to see what others think, but to see how I feel about it. Does it bring me joy? (Something I’m entitled to, especially now!) Does it need a bit of editorial spiffing up? Whatever….just being in the process is energizing for me. It means I’ve done my best for now and–best of all–have a record of it! I guess I’m describing something like a conversation that happens internally and on paper. At this age, it almost (!) doesn’t matter whether I ‘finish’ it or not. 🙂
Elouise
Fran Macilvey
September 25, 2017 @ 6:10 pm
Dear Elouise,
What a lovely comment! I can hear you writing it, if you know what I mean. I have been a perfectionist, and the world’s best procrastinator, which is a wonderful way of saying, I acquired the skill for doing zilch. Sometimes, I admit, that feels wonderful, other times, it’s like my wheels need more grease than I can find to get them moving. But one shove usually does it. Even if that is a friend saying, ‘FGS get a move on, honey!’ 🙂
Thanks for being such a fun friend. ((XXX))